The rise of pistol-mounted optics has transformed the landscape of handgun shooting, enhancing both precision and speed. Two primary methods have emerged for mounting optics on pistols: optic cut pistol slides and optic-ready plate systems. Each has distinct advantages and potential drawbacks, making it important for shooters to understand their differences before deciding which system to use. This article will compare these two methods, discussing their design, benefits, challenges, and ideal applications.
1. Design and Functionality
Optic Cut Pistol Slides are custom slides or factory slides modified with a direct cut to accommodate a specific optic. The slide is machined to fit the base of the optic, often providing a low-profile mount that allows the optic to sit closer to the bore axis. This design often results in a more streamlined appearance and can reduce the potential for the optic to snag on clothing or holsters.
On the other hand, Optic-Ready Plate Systems involve a pistol slide that comes pre-cut to accommodate various optics through the use of interchangeable plates. These plates act as adapters, allowing users to mount different optics without needing to modify the slide further. This system is modular and flexible, catering to users who may want to switch between optics or try different brands without committing to a permanent cut.
2. Advantages
a. Optic Cut Pistol Slides
- Low Profile: One of the main advantages of optic cut slides is the low profile they offer. Since the optic is mounted directly into the slide, it often sits lower than in a plate system, which can improve sight acquisition and target tracking. A lower optic also aligns more closely with the bore, potentially reducing recoil impulse effects.
- Durability and Stability: By integrating the optic directly into the slide, the mount tends to be more stable and durable. There are fewer points of contact and fewer components involved, reducing the chances of screws loosening or plates shifting under recoil.
- Aesthetics: Some shooters prefer the sleeker look of a direct optic cut, as it appears as an integrated part of the pistol rather than an add-on. The seamless design can also reduce the risk of the optic catching on clothing during concealed carry.
b. Optic-Ready Plate Systems
- Versatility: The primary benefit of the optic-ready plate system is its versatility. Since the system uses adapter plates, shooters can easily switch between different optics without needing to purchase or modify another slide. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for those who own multiple optics or are still experimenting to find the one that best suits their needs.
- Future-Proofing: As optic technology advances, new models with different mounting footprints are regularly introduced. An optic-ready plate system allows users to upgrade their optics without needing a new slide or additional modifications. This feature is particularly valuable for those who want to stay current with the latest optic innovations.
- Accessibility: Optic-ready slides with plate systems are often more accessible to a broader audience, as they can be found on many factory pistols from various manufacturers. This feature makes it easier for new shooters to try out red dot sights without needing to invest in custom slide work.
3. Challenges
a. Optic Cut Pistol Slides
- Limited Compatibility: One of the major drawbacks of an optic cut slide is its lack of versatility. Since the slide is cut specifically for one optic, changing to a different optic requires a new slide or additional milling. This limitation can be restrictive for those who may want to experiment with different optics over time.
- Permanent Modification: Optic cuts are a permanent modification to the slide, making it difficult to revert to iron sights if desired. Additionally, if the optic cut is not perfectly executed, it can compromise the reliability of the optic or the pistol itself.
- Cost: Having a slide custom-milled for a specific optic can be costly, particularly when compared to purchasing a factory optic-ready pistol. The cost of the slide work, combined with the expense of the optic, can add up quickly, making this option less appealing to budget-conscious shooters.
b. Optic-Ready Plate Systems
- Higher Profile: Optic plate systems typically result in the optic sitting higher on the slide, which can affect sight acquisition and the pistol’s overall balance. A higher-mounted optic may require taller iron sights to co-witness, which can further alter the pistol’s ergonomics.
- Potential for Looseness: Since the optic is mounted to an adapter plate rather than directly to the slide, there are more components involved, increasing the potential for screws to loosen or plates to shift under recoil. This issue can be mitigated with proper installation and maintenance, but it remains a consideration for those who prioritize reliability.
- Complexity: The modularity of the plate system, while an advantage in terms of versatility, also introduces additional complexity. Users need to ensure they are using the correct plate and hardware for their optic, and improper installation can lead to functional issues.
4. Applications
a. Ideal Scenarios for Optic Cut Pistol Slides
- Dedicated Competition Guns: For competitive shooters who have chosen a specific optic for their setup, an optic cut slide offers the most streamlined and reliable mounting solution. The low profile and stability are particularly advantageous in high-speed, high-precision scenarios where every fraction of a second counts.
- Concealed Carry: Shooters who carry concealed may prefer the lower profile of an optic cut slide, as it reduces the risk of snagging and can improve comfort during daily carry. The reduced bulk also contributes to better concealability.
- Long-Term Commitment: Those who are committed to a particular optic and do not plan to change it may find the optic cut slide to be the most efficient and aesthetically pleasing option.
b. Ideal Scenarios for Optic-Ready Plate Systems
- Versatile Setups: Shooters who want to experiment with different optics or use a single pistol for multiple purposes may find the optic-ready plate system more accommodating. This system allows for easy transitions between optics for different applications, such as competition, duty, or home defense.
- New to Optics: Individuals new to pistol optics may prefer the flexibility of a plate system, as it provides an opportunity to try various options without committing to a single setup. This approach can be particularly useful during the learning phase, where preferences may change as experience grows.
- Budget Considerations: For those on a tighter budget, an optic-ready plate system can be a more economical choice. The ability to use one slide for multiple optics saves money and allows for gradual upgrades over time.
5. Conclusion
The choice between an optic cut pistol slide and an optic-ready plate system ultimately depends on the shooter’s specific needs, preferences, and intended applications. Optic cut slides offer a lower profile, increased durability, and a sleek appearance but come with limitations in versatility and potential higher costs. Optic-ready plate systems provide unmatched flexibility and future-proofing, making them ideal for those who value versatility and experimentation.
This is an optic specific cut from Angled Spade Technologies.
For competitive shooters, dedicated concealed carriers, and those who have settled on a specific optic, the optic cut slide may be the best option. However, for new shooters, those who own multiple optics, or anyone looking to keep their options open, the optic-ready plate system offers a level of adaptability that can’t be matched by a single optic cut.
Citations:
- Langdon, Ernest. “Mounting Red Dot Optics on Handguns.” Langdon Tactical Technology, 2021.
- Vickers, Larry. “Pros and Cons of Pistol Optics: What You Need to Know.” Vickers Tactical, 2020.
- American Rifleman Staff. “Handgun Optics Mounting Systems: What Works Best for You?” American Rifleman, 2023.
- “Optic Ready vs. Direct Mounting: A Shooter’s Guide.” Guns & Ammo, 2022.
If you like what you see, please check out other ANR Media by following the link below! https://linktr.ee/ANRDESIGNLLC
Here you can find the ANR Design Website, YouTube, Facebook Business Page, Twitter, and Twitch Accounts! Podcast Streaming!
Amazon Music https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/7b31bd97-c8b0-4926-be87-b7a073f07976/ANR-Unholstered
Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/1AKResNkCXDDJpgvCgSJFc
Google https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zaW1wbGVjYXN0LmNvbS84dU53WjV4OQ
Apple https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/anr-design-unholstered/id1561628365